Document Type
Article
Publication Title
Mathematics
Abstract
For rare disease drug development, the United States (US) Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has indicated that the same standards as those for drug products for common conditions will be applied. To assist the sponsors in rare disease drug development, the FDA has initiated several incentive programs to encourage the sponsors in rare disease drug development. In practice, these incentive programs may not help in achieving the study objectives due to the limited small patient population. To overcome this problem, some out-of-the-box innovative thinking and/or approaches, without jeopardizing the integrity, quality, and scientific validity of rare disease drug development, are necessarily considered. These innovative thinking and/or approaches include but are not limited to (i) sample size justification based on probability statements rather than conventional power analysis; (ii) demonstrating not-ineffectiveness and not-unsafeness rather than demonstrating effectiveness and safety with the small patient population (i.e., limited sample size) available; (iii) the use of complex innovative designs such as a two-stage seamless adaptive trial design and/or an n-of-1 trial design for flexibility and the efficient assessment of the test treatment under study; (iv) using real-world data (RWD) and real-world evidence (RWE) to support regulatory submission; and (v) conducting an individual benefit–risk assessment for a complete picture of the clinical performance of the test treatment under investigation. In this article, we provide a comprehensive summarization of this innovative thinking and these approaches for an efficient, accurate and reliable assessment of a test treatment used for treating patients with rare diseases under study. Statistical considerations including challenges and justifications are provided whenever possible. In addition, an innovative approach that combines innovative thinking and these approaches is proposed for regulatory consideration in rare disease drug development.
DOI
10.3390/math12050631
Publication Date
2-21-2024
Keywords
composite hypotheses, demonstrating not-ineffectiveness and not-unsafeness, randomized clinical trial (RCT), real-world data (RWD), orphan drug development
ISSN
2227-7390
Recommended Citation
Chow S, Pong A, Chow SS. Novel Design and Analysis for Rare Disease Drug Development. Mathematics. 2024; 12(5). doi: 10.3390/math12050631.
